From 1933 through 1945, after New York was apportioned two extra seats in the United States House of Representatives, the state elected those two seats At-large, instead of from districts. For the 79th United States Congress, which began in 1945, the state redistricted its seats and assigned its 45 representatives to 45 seats, thereby eliminating At-large representation.
| Representative | Party | Years | District home | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| John Fitzgibbons | Democratic | 1933-1935 | ||
| Matthew J. Merritt | Democratic | 1935-01-03-1945-01-03 | Retired |
| Representative | Party | Years | District home | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elmer E. Studley | Democratic | 1933-1935 | ||
| Caroline O'Day | Democratic | 1935-1943 | ||
| Winifred C. Stanley | Republican | 1943-01-03-1945-01-03 | Retired |