|
→Merge proposal: Reply
|
→Merge proposal: Closing
|
||
Line 71:
== Merge proposal ==
{{Discussion top|result=Not merged - there is a clear consensus against a merge here, and a view that the two sets of films are distinct enough for their own articles. Discussion about a potential overarching article seems to be addressed by the existence of [[Middle-earth in motion pictures]]. [[User:Turnagra|Turnagra]] ([[User talk:Turnagra|talk]]) 03:21, 1 June 2024 (UTC)}}
I propose merging [[The Hobbit (film series)]] into [[The Lord of the Rings (film series)]]. As has been pointed out in previous conversations, and by other editors besides myself -- ''The Lord of the Rings'' film series includes the original ''LOTR'' film trilogy, ''The Hobbit'' prequel trilogy, and now the 2 upcoming standalone prequel films: ''The War of the Rohirrim'' and ''The Hunt for Gollum''. To have 2 separate articles for the film trilogies is both excessive and inconsistent. For comparison, I would refer all editors to the ''Star Wars'', ''Star Trek'', ''X-Men'', and ''Wizarding World'' articles. Each of these articles include multiple trilogies and installments. None of them require an individual page for each trilogy. As was also pointed out by other editors, it has been attempted at various times to condense these articles and create one detailed replacement for the film series -- but it continues to be reverted. Please engage in discussion below, and include why/why not you believe this merger should happen. I will post a similar alert on ''The Hobbit'' film series current article talk page.[[User:DisneyMetalhead|DisneyMetalhead]] ([[User talk:DisneyMetalhead|talk]]) 06:09, 17 May 2024 (UTC)
Line 98:
:: Could somebody please close this as [[WP:SNOW]]. Many thanks. [[User:Chiswick Chap|Chiswick Chap]] ([[User talk:Chiswick Chap|talk]]) 14:45, 22 May 2024 (UTC)
{{Discussion bottom}}
| |||