Primeval history: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 22:52, 10 December 2023

The body of material tells how God created the world and all its beings and placed the first man and woman (Adam and Eve) in his Garden of Eden, how the first couple were expelled from God's presence, of the first murder which followed, and God's decision to destroy the world and save only the righteous Noah and his sons; a new humanity then descended from these sons and spread throughout the world, but, although the new world was as sinful as the old, God resolved never again to destroy the world by flood, and the history ended with Terah, the father of Abraham, from whom descended God's chosen people.^[2]

The primeval history is generally considered to have been completed along with the rest of the Book of Genesis in the 5th century BCE, but a sizeable minority of scholars have dated it to the 3rd century BCE, pointing to discontinuities between the contents of the work and other parts of the Hebrew Bible.

Structure and content[edit]

The history contains some of the best-known stories in the Bible plus a number of genealogies, structured around the five-fold repetition of the toledot formula ("These are the generations of..."):^[3]

Composition history[edit]

Sources in Genesis[edit]

Scholars generally agree that the Torah, the collection of five books of which Genesis is the first, achieved something like its current form in the 5th century BCE.^[4] However, the almost complete absence of all the characters and incidents mentioned in the Primeval history from the rest of the Hebrew Bible has led a sizeable minority of scholars to conclude that these chapters were composed much later than those that follow, possibly in the 3rd century BC.^[5]

Genesis draws on a number of distinct "sources", including the Priestly source, the Yahwist and the Elohist – the last two are often referred to collectively as "non-Priestly", but the Elohist is not present in the primeval history and "non-Priestly" and "Yahwist" can be regarded here as interchangeable terms.^[6] The following table is based on Robert Kugler and Patrick Hartin, "An Introduction to the Bible", 2009:^[7]

Verse	Priestly	Yahwist
1:1–2:4a	Creation story A	—
2:4b–4:26	—	Creation story B Garden of Eden Cain and Abel
5:1–24	Descendants of Adam	—
6:1–8	—	Nephilim Reason for the Flood
6:9–13	Reason for the Flood	—
6:14–8:22	Flood Renewal after Flood
9:1–17	—	Noahide covenant
9:18–27	Noah's drunkenness Sons of Noah Curse of Canaan
10:1–32	Table of Nations
11:1–9	—	Tower of Babel
11:10–32	Descendants of Noah	—

Relationship of the primeval history to Genesis 12–50[edit]

Genesis 1–11 shows little relationship to the remainder of Genesis.^[8] For example, the names of its characters and its geography – Adam (man) and Eve (life), the Land of Nod ("Wandering"), and so on – are symbolic rather than real, and much of the narratives consist of lists of "firsts": the first murder, the first wine, the first empire-builder.^[9] Most notably, almost none of the persons, places and stories in it are ever mentioned anywhere else in the Bible.^[9] This has led some scholars to suppose that the history forms a late composition attached to Genesis and the Pentateuch to serve as an introduction.^[10] Just how late is a subject for debate: at one extreme are those who see it as a product of the Hellenistic period, in which case it cannot be earlier than the first decades of the 4th century BCE;^[5] on the other hand the Yahwist source has been dated by some scholars, notably John Van Seters, to the exilic pre-Persian period (the 6th century BCE) precisely because the primeval history contains so much Babylonian influence in the form of myth.^[11]^{[Note 1]} David M. Carr argues that the latest edition of the pre-Priestly version of the narratives probably dates to the mid-7th century BCE, during the period of Neo-Assyrian hegemony.^[12]

Mesopotamian (and Egyptian) myths and the primeval history[edit]

Numerous Mesopotamian myths (and one Egyptian myth) are reflected in the primeval history.^[13] The myth of Atrahasis, for example, was the first to record a Great Flood, and may lie behind the story of Noah's flood.^[14] The following table sets out the myths behind the various Biblical tropes.^[15]

Bible story	Mesopotamian (Egyptian) myth
Genesis creation narrative: Genesis 1	Enuma Elish, the Babylonian creation myth, has a very similar opening to Genesis 1, refers to such entities as the "Deep" (Hebrew Tehom), arrives at a cosmology very similar to the one in Genesis 1:6, and shows a similar concern for reckoning time through the creation of heavenly bodies. God's creation of mankind in his image also recalls Mesopotamian myths, as does man's sovereignty over nature. In addition, the way God creates through the spoken word in Genesis 1 mirrors the Egyptian Memphite Theology in which the god Ptah creates the world through speech.
Genesis creation narrative: Genesis 2	The Atrahasis epic tells how the gods created mankind from dust
Garden of Eden	The god and goddess Enki and Ninhursag enjoyed a Tree of Life; the serpent in Genesis recalls the god Apsu in the Enuma Elish.
Cain and Abel	Cain and Abel are paralleled by the gods Dumuzi and Enkimdu
Genealogies	The Sumerian King List, like the list of the descendants of Cain, explains the origin of the elements of civilisation. Enoch, seventh in the line of Adam and taken by God, mirrors the king Enmerduranki and the sage Utuabzu, also seventh in their lines, taken to dwell with the gods.^[16]^[17]
Genesis flood narrative	The great deluge is told in a number of versions beginning in the early 2nd millennium; like the later Genesis myth, they tell how humanity survives through one hero and his family.
Tower of Babel (Genesis 11)	While there is no Mesopotamian myth associated with the Tower of Babel, there is scholarly agreement that Babylonian ziggurats, or tower-temples, lie behind this story.

Themes and theology[edit]

Creation, destruction and re-creation[edit]

The history tells how God creates a world which is good (each action within Genesis 1 ends with God marking it as good),^[18] and how evil contaminates it through disobedience (the Eden story) and violence (Cain and Abel).^[1]

Chronology[edit]

The Genesis creation narrative marks the start of the Biblical chronology, the elaborate system of markers, both hidden and overt, marking off a fictive 4000 year history of the world.^[19]^{[Note 2]} From Creation to Abraham, time is calculated by adding the ages of the Patriarchs when their first child is born.^[20] It seems possible that the period of the Flood is not meant to be included in the count^[21] – for example, Shem, born 100 years before the Flood, "begot" his first son two years after it, which should make him 102, but Genesis 11:10–11 specifies that he is only 100, suggesting that time has been suspended.^[22] The period from the birth of Shem's third son Arpachshad (in the second year after the Flood) to Abraham's migration to Canaan is 365 years,^[23] mirroring Enoch's life-span of 365 years, the number of days in a year.^[24] There are 10 Patriarchs between Adam and the Flood and 10 between the Flood and Abraham – the Septuagint adds an extra ancestor so that the second group is 10 from the Flood to Terah.^[25] Noah and Terah each have three sons, of whom the first in each case is the most important.^[26]

Contents

Primeval history: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 22:52, 10 December 2023

Structure and content[edit]

Composition history[edit]

Sources in Genesis[edit]

Relationship of the primeval history to Genesis 12–50[edit]

Mesopotamian (and Egyptian) myths and the primeval history[edit]

Themes and theology[edit]

Creation, destruction and re-creation[edit]

Chronology[edit]

See also[edit]

Notes[edit]

References[edit]

Citations[edit]

Bibliography[edit]