|
No edit summary
|
||
Line 26: | Line 26: | ||
:::Each and every one of your own-book-promoting references were changed so that they directed readers to a particular page in either Braid's ''Neurypnology'' or Bramwell's ''Hypnotism'', two works that were not only "fully readable", but, also, "fully downloadable". Perhaps, you could consider make the entire book a "'''FULL VIEW'''" and "fully downloadable" on Google; otherwise, the references to Braid and Bramwell must stand. |
:::Each and every one of your own-book-promoting references were changed so that they directed readers to a particular page in either Braid's ''Neurypnology'' or Bramwell's ''Hypnotism'', two works that were not only "fully readable", but, also, "fully downloadable". Perhaps, you could consider make the entire book a "'''FULL VIEW'''" and "fully downloadable" on Google; otherwise, the references to Braid and Bramwell must stand. |
||
:::Also, not commercial? [http://www.facebook.com/notes/james-braid/new-book-the-complete-writings-of-james-braid/60357742355] "This book has been published to help raise the profile of NCH by spreading its name as publisher around the net"[[Special:Contributions/129.94.78.159|129.94.78.159]] ([[User talk:129.94.78.159|talk]]) 06:56, 19 November 2009 (UTC) |
:::Also, not commercial? [http://www.facebook.com/notes/james-braid/new-book-the-complete-writings-of-james-braid/60357742355] "This book has been published to help raise the profile of NCH by spreading its name as publisher around the net"[[Special:Contributions/129.94.78.159|129.94.78.159]] ([[User talk:129.94.78.159|talk]]) 06:56, 19 November 2009 (UTC) |
||
:::You seem to be adopting a bit of a hostile attitude for some reason, and you're also mistaken. The whole book can be searched and read on Google, limited preview just means that there's a limit on how many pages you can view at a time, to prevent copying. As mentioned above, NCH is a NON-profit organisation whereas, I think you'll find that most publishers are profit-making commercial enterprises. I referenced content against my own complete edition of Braid's writings because it's the only version that's currently in print and because it contains material by Braid which is not in the edition of Neurypnology you're talking about. --[[User:HypnoSynthesis|HypnoSynthesis]] ([[User talk:HypnoSynthesis|talk]]) 21:02, 19 November 2009 (UTC) |
![]() | Biography Start‑class | ||||||
|
There are very very few citations in this article. I've marked where I would like to see some.
LookingGlass (talk) 13:39, 7 August 2009 (UTC)[reply]
I'm Donald Robertson, the author of The Discovery of Hypnosis, a new edition of Braid's writings, and the only place where most of his works are published. I previously added some references to Braid's writings, published in the complete edition which someone has now anonymously removed. They've added a comment to their revisions which states: "Setting up better references that are not conected with the promotion of a commercial organization, plus other corrections and amendments." I assume what they mean is that the complete edition of Braid's writings is published by the National Council for Hypnotherapy. To set the record straight, unlike most publishing houses, this is actually a *non-profit* organisation. I therefore think it's a bit unreasonable to systematically purge any references to a book just because it's published by them.
The person who made these edits also introduced some errors into the article. For example, the article I published in IJCEH was not translated by Hilary Norris-Evans, she simply advised on minor amendments to my own translation. I'm not sure about the claim that this article was a loose translation of a German article, as far as I'm aware, it was translated into French from the English original; it's prefaced by an introduction in French by Braid himself addressed to the French Academy of Sciences and so the French translation seems to predate Preyer's German version, contrary to the comments added to the article. --HypnoSynthesis (talk) 07:46, 17 November 2009 (UTC)[reply]