Talk:Nightfall (Asimov novelette and novel): Difference between revisions

{{WikiProject banner shell|class=Start|

{{WikiProject Novels|importance=Mid

|short-story-task-force=yes

|sf-task-force=yes

}}

{{WikiProject Science Fiction|importance=Mid}}

}}

:Asimov was well read in ancient history, so he probably didn't make the name up. [[User:PatGallacher|PatGallacher]] ([[User talk:PatGallacher|talk]]) 19:08, 17 April 2022 (UTC)

:Yes, there is evidence. Asimov addressed this in his autobiography "I. Asimov," in the context of Robert Silverberg's novelization of the story:

{{Blockquote|text=Bob changed the name of the planet and of one character in “Nightfall” because I had made deliberate use of Sumerian and Egyptian names to lend strangeness without too much strangeness. Bob thought that a mistake and wanted nothing to be too reminiscent of Earth, and he may have been right.}}

:[[User:Darkday|Darkday]] ([[User talk:Darkday|talk]]) 12:57, 13 November 2022 (UTC)

== Confusing sentence ==

We have this sentence: "As stated in the introduction, the weather in the book is analogous to the meteorologic experiences of the characters in the book". So (1) what introduction does this reference? The article's lede does not mention weather at all. And (2) what does this sentence even mean?

FWIW, the sentence itself seems to have very little relevance either to the plot or to the story's significance. Delete? [[User:Jmacwiki|Jmacwiki]] ([[User talk:Jmacwiki|talk]]) 21:14, 29 September 2021 (UTC)

:True the sentence is nonsensical. The book's weather is not analogous to the meteorological experiences of the characters. The weather '''is''' the meteorological experience – that is, I believe, the definition of weather. The introduction is the book's introduction. In parts, the book's weather reflects the characters' moods. In other places the characters' moods are greatly affected by the weather. (That is rather like real life.)

:I'm editing the offending sentence so that it makes sense. Please feel free to improve or delete my efforts. [[User:OrewaTel|OrewaTel]] ([[User talk:OrewaTel|talk]]) 01:15, 30 September 2021 (UTC)

== about how much Asimov got paid for his Nightfall short story ==

November 18, 2022:-I am reading ''Nightfall and Other Stories''<nowiki> published 2021 by Del Rey Trade Paperback Edition, copyright 1969 by Isaac Asimov. He wrote a preface to Nightfall, and on page 4, he said the check was $150.00 from the editor John Campbell, who paid Asimov a bonus of 1/4 cent a word. Not $166. The first appearance of the story was September 1941, in Astounding Science Fiction, by Street & Smith Publications, Inc. I only want to correct the "facts" out there in the internet. If someone can verify this, great. Thank you. ~~~~ecila</nowiki> [[User:Ecilauhc|ecila]] ([[User talk:Ecilauhc|talk]]) 20:08, 18 November 2022 (UTC)

:$166 is the correct number. Asimov cleared that up in 1972 in ''The Early Asimov'':

{{Quote box|quote = In telling the story, in that collection [''Nightfall and Other Stories''], of how “Nightfall” came to be written, I mentioned that I had received $150 for it, quoting from memory. Once again, I must confess fallibility. The records say $166. It is a small point, and perhaps not worth noting, but I know my readers. By explaining this now, I fend off dozens of letters that will mention the discrepancy and demand an explanation.}}

:[[User:Darkday|Darkday]] ([[User talk:Darkday|talk]]) 00:00, 19 November 2022 (UTC)

== Article Categories ==

There seems to be a tendency to add categories without checking their relevance. In particular, this article is called Post-apocalyptic. Yes there are historical apocalyptic events but story is about a recurring disaster. The short story deals with the run up and the actual apocalypse. Maybe the short story should be in the Pre-apocalyptic category. The novel talks about the post disaster society and so that part of the article is indeed post-apocalyptic.

The other category is American Philosophy. It's a story and like all good works of fiction it examines emotions, feelings and the consequent actions of the protagonists but 'Philosophy'? No. I don't think so. And why ''American'' Philosophy? For sure the authors are American but the protagonists are just folks.Their reactions seem to be international rather than parochial. [[User:OrewaTel|OrewaTel]] ([[User talk:OrewaTel|talk]]) 05:41, 29 December 2022 (UTC)