[B! あとで読む] 宇佐美典也 @usaminoriya 【重要：WBPC問題事務連絡】本日浜田聡事務所にて総務省から地方自治法のレクを受けたのちに、弁護士を交えてWBPC問題について議論して論点整理しましたのでその結果報共有します。（*総務省自身は地方自治を尊重するため一般論のみを述べ、個別事案に対するスタンスを示さず）以下細かい法律的な議論が入るので、結論を端的にいえば「東京都の答弁は、ほぼ100%ウソと詭弁だけで構成されており、追及する必要がある」ということです。

リンクを埋め込む

以下のコードをコピーしてサイトに埋め込むことができます

<iframe marginwidth="0" marginheight="0" src="https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry.parts?url=https%3A%2F%2Ftwitter.com%2Fusaminoriya%2Fstatus%2F1651158399487471619%3Fs%3D12%26t%3DUbvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" scrolling="no" frameborder="0" height="230" width="500"><div class="hatena-bookmark-detail-info"><div class="tategaki" style="margin-top:10px;width:100%;clear:left;"><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">宇</span><span class="char"">佐</span><span class="char"">美</span><span class="char"">典</span><span class="char"">也</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">@</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">u</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">s</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">a</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">m</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">i</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">n</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">o</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">r</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">i</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">y</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">a</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">︻</span><span class="char"">重</span><span class="char"">要</span><span class="char"">‥</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">W</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">B</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">P</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">C</span><span class="char"">問</span><span class="char"">題</span><span class="char"">事</span><span class="char"">務</span><span class="char"">連</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">絡</span><span class="char"">︼</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">本</span><span class="char"">日</span><span class="char"">浜</span><span class="char"">田</span><span class="char"">聡</span><span class="char"">事</span><span class="char"">務</span><span class="char"">所</span><span class="char"">に</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">総</span><span class="char"">務</span><span class="char"">省</span><span class="char"">か</span><span class="char"">ら</span><span class="char"">地</span><span class="char"">方</span><span class="char"">自</span><span class="char"">治</span><span class="char"">法</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">レ</span><span class="char"">ク</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">受</span><span class="char"">け</span><span class="char"">た</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">ち</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">に</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">弁</span><span class="char"">護</span><span class="char"">士</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">交</span><span class="char"">え</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">W</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">B</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">P</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">C</span><span class="char"">問</span><span class="char"">題</span><span class="char"">に</span><span class="char"">つ</span><span class="char"">い</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">議</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">し</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">点</span><span class="char"">整</span><span class="char"">理</span><span class="char"">し</span><span class="char"">ま</span><span class="char"">し</span><span class="char"">た</span><span class="char"">の</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">で</span><span class="char"">そ</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">結</span><span class="char"">果</span><span class="char"">報</span><span class="char"">共</span><span class="char"">有</span><span class="char"">し</span><span class="char"">ま</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="ku-ten">。</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">︵</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">*</span><span class="char"">総</span><span class="char"">務</span><span class="char"">省</span><span class="char"">自</span><span class="char"">身</span><span class="char"">は</span><span class="char"">地</span><span class="char"">方</span><span class="char"">自</span><span class="char"">治</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">尊</span><span class="char"">重</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">た</span><span class="char"">め</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">一</span><span class="char"">般</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">み</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">述</span><span class="char"">べ</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">個</span><span class="char"">別</span><span class="char"">事</span><span class="char"">案</span><span class="char"">に</span><span class="char"">対</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">ス</span><span class="char"">タ</span><span class="char"">ン</span><span class="char"">ス</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">示</span><span class="char"">さ</span><span class="char"">ず</span><span class="char"">︶</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">以</span><span class="char"">下</span><span class="char"">細</span><span class="char"">か</span><span class="char"">い</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">法</span><span class="char"">律</span><span class="char"">的</span><span class="char"">な</span><span class="char"">議</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">が</span><span class="char"">入</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">で</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">結</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">端</span><span class="char"">的</span><span class="char"">に</span><span class="char"">い</span><span class="char"">え</span><span class="char"">ば</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">﹁</span><span class="char"">東</span><span class="char"">京</span><span class="char"">都</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">答</span><span class="char"">弁</span><span class="char"">は</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">ほ</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">ぼ</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">1</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">0</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">0</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">%</span><span class="char"">ウ</span><span class="char"">ソ</span><span class="char"">と</span><span class="char"">詭</span><span class="char"">弁</span><span class="char"">だ</span><span class="char"">け</span><span class="char"">で</span><span class="char"">構</span><span class="char"">成</span><span class="char"">さ</span><span class="char"">れ</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">お</span><span class="char"">り</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">追</span><span class="char"">及</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">必</span><span class="char"">要</span><span class="char"">が</span><span class="char"">あ</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">﹂</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">と</span><span class="char"">い</span><span class="char"">う</span><span class="char"">こ</span><span class="char"">と</span><span class="char"">で</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="ku-ten">。</span></a><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry/s/twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">は</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">な</span><span class="char"">ブ</span><span class="kogaki">ッ</span><span class="char"">ク</span><span class="char"">マ</span><span class="cho-on" style="width:19px;height:19px;">ー</span><span class="char"">ク</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">-</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">宇</span><span class="char"">佐</span><span class="char"">美</span><span class="char"">典</span><span class="char"">也</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">@</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">u</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">s</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">a</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">m</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">i</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry/s/twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">n</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">o</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">r</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">i</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">y</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">a</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">︻</span><span class="char"">重</span><span class="char"">要</span><span class="char"">‥</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">W</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">B</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">P</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">C</span><span class="char"">問</span><span class="char"">題</span><span class="char"">事</span><span class="char"">務</span><span class="char"">連</span><span class="char"">絡</span><span class="char"">︼</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">本</span><span class="char"">日</span><span class="char"">浜</span><span class="char"">田</span><span class="char"">聡</span><span class="char"">事</span><span class="char"">務</span><span class="char"">所</span><span class="char"">に</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry/s/twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">総</span><span class="char"">務</span><span class="char"">省</span><span class="char"">か</span><span class="char"">ら</span><span class="char"">地</span><span class="char"">方</span><span class="char"">自</span><span class="char"">治</span><span class="char"">法</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">レ</span><span class="char"">ク</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">受</span><span class="char"">け</span><span class="char"">た</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">ち</span><span class="char"">に</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">弁</span><span class="char"">護</span><span class="char"">士</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">交</span><span class="char"">え</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">W</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">B</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">P</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry/s/twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">C</span><span class="char"">問</span><span class="char"">題</span><span class="char"">に</span><span class="char"">つ</span><span class="char"">い</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">議</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">し</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">点</span><span class="char"">整</span><span class="char"">理</span><span class="char"">し</span><span class="char"">ま</span><span class="char"">し</span><span class="char"">た</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">で</span><span class="char"">そ</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">結</span><span class="char"">果</span><span class="char"">報</span><span class="char"">共</span><span class="char"">有</span><span class="char"">し</span><span class="char"">ま</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="ku-ten">。</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry/s/twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">︵</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">*</span><span class="char"">総</span><span class="char"">務</span><span class="char"">省</span><span class="char"">自</span><span class="char"">身</span><span class="char"">は</span><span class="char"">地</span><span class="char"">方</span><span class="char"">自</span><span class="char"">治</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">尊</span><span class="char"">重</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">た</span><span class="char"">め</span><span class="char"">一</span><span class="char"">般</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">み</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">述</span><span class="char"">べ</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">個</span><span class="char"">別</span><span class="char"">事</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry/s/twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">案</span><span class="char"">に</span><span class="char"">対</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">ス</span><span class="char"">タ</span><span class="char"">ン</span><span class="char"">ス</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">示</span><span class="char"">さ</span><span class="char"">ず</span><span class="char"">︶</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">以</span><span class="char"">下</span><span class="char"">細</span><span class="char"">か</span><span class="char"">い</span><span class="char"">法</span><span class="char"">律</span><span class="char"">的</span><span class="char"">な</span><span class="char"">議</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">が</span><span class="char"">入</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">で</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry/s/twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">結</span><span class="char"">論</span><span class="char"">を</span><span class="char"">端</span><span class="char"">的</span><span class="char"">に</span><span class="char"">い</span><span class="char"">え</span><span class="char"">ば</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">﹁</span><span class="char"">東</span><span class="char"">京</span><span class="char"">都</span><span class="char"">の</span><span class="char"">答</span><span class="char"">弁</span><span class="char"">は</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">ほ</span><span class="char"">ぼ</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">1</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">0</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">0</span><span class="latin" style="width:19px;height:19px;">%</span><span class="char"">ウ</span><span class="char"">ソ</span><span class="char"">と</span><span class="char"">詭</span><span class="char"">弁</span><span class="char"">だ</span><span class="char"">け</span></a></span><span class="tktr-gyo" style="height:640px;margin:0 0 180px 22px;font-size:19px;_width:19px;/width:19px;"><a href="https://akarinohon.com/text/taketori.cgi/https://b.hatena.ne.jp/entry/s/twitter.com/usaminoriya/status/1651158399487471619%253Fs=12&t=Ubvyt8RzmWc8gGdq1fD22g" style="padding:0;text-decoration:none;display:block;border-top:none;border-bottom:none;margin:0;"><span class="char"">で</span><span class="char"">構</span><span class="char"">成</span><span class="char"">さ</span><span class="char"">れ</span><span class="char"">て</span><span class="char"">お</span><span class="char"">り</span><span class="tou-ten">、</span><span class="char"">追</span><span class="char"">及</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">必</span><span class="char"">要</span><span class="char"">が</span><span class="char"">あ</span><span class="char"">る</span><span class="char"">﹂</span><span class="latin" style="display:block;width:19px;height:19px;"> </span><span class="char"">と</span><span class="char"">い</span><span class="char"">う</span><span class="char"">こ</span><span class="char"">と</span><span class="char"">で</span><span class="char"">す</span><span class="ku-ten">。</span></a></span><span style="display:block;clear:right"></span></div></div></iframe>