| 2022 Leicester unrest | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Date | 28 August 2022 – 24 September 2022 | ||
| Location | |||
| Caused by | Cricket match brawls Anti-Hindu sentiment[1][2] | ||
| Methods | Fighting, vandalism | ||
| Parties | |||
| Lead figures | |||
|
| |||
| Casualties | |||
| Injuries | 25 police officers | ||
| Arrested | 47 | ||
In August and September 2022, Leicester, England, saw a period of religious and ethnic tension between predominately British Hindus and British MuslimsofSouth Asian origin. The unrest saw rioting, protest marches, sloganeering and ethnic violence between the two populations. It was also preceded by social media campaigning, misinformation and hate propaganda. Muslim side speakers without evidence tried whitewashing their reasoning for the riots on Hinduphobic propaganda terms like "Hindutva fascism" entering their neighbourhoods as the driver behind the unrest,[1][2] Subsequent independent investigations found Hindu places of worship were attacked and desecerated by Muslim mobs[5] and Hindu men specifically targeted by mobs. Muslim community leaders and analysts point to the Indian celebrations following the India–Pakistan 2022 Asia Cup match on 28 August as a catalyst, which saw a reaction from Pakistani fans.[6]
1km
0.6miles
Like most British cities, Leicester has significant and growing South Asian British populations. Leicester is known for its ethnic diversity, and is one of three cities in England where the White British population are a minority. Since the end of the Second World War, the city has seen successive waves of migration, with immigrants from the Indian sub-continent arriving in the 1960s, followed by South Asians arriving from Kenya and Uganda in the early 1970s.[7] By 2021, Leicester's population was 33% Muslim and 25% Hindu.[8]
Muslims, predominantly working class,[citation needed] live in eastern Leicester (LE5 postcode), with particular concentration in the Spinney Hills and North Evington neighbourhoods.[9][10] Hindus predominantly live in north Leicester (LE4 postcode), mainly in the Belgrave area.[11]
The ‘spatial polarization’ developed since the 1970s, with the Belgrave area (a former working class neighbourhood) becoming home to affluent Indian-origin East African Hindus.[12][13]
Scholar Ayesha Siddiqa points out the growing extremism among British Muslims, owing to several factors such as the welcome given to Muslim clergy as a partner in the Afghan wars and the various geopolitical developments that brought various extremist ideologies to congregate in Britain.[14] The Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) that came to power in India, along with prime minister Narendra Modi, is expected to have had high levels of support among the Hindus in UK.[15] This is also likely to have increased frictions between the communities because the Muslim press propaganda tended to describe the BJP as "Fascist" because of their Hinduphobic tendencies to varying degrees.[16]
The British party politics is seen to have caused polarisation between the two communities, with Muslims siding with the Labour Party and Hindus siding with the Conservative Party. The 2019 general election was not only a "Brexit and NHS election", but also a "Kashmir election" according to The Guardian columnist Sunny Hundal. This was a reference to the Modi Government's decisive action in the complete integration of Kashmir into India in 2019, and the corresponding backlash in Pakistan. These developments had reactions in British Hindu and Muslim communities.[17] Rutgers University's Network Contagion Research Institute (NCRI), which has investigated the online trends between 2019 and 2022, noted a wide dispersion of anti-Hindu and anti-India slurs and tropes during this period.[18] Anti-Hindu memes accompanied by pejoratives such as "pajeet" (slur for Indian or Hindu), "streetshitter", "poojeet", "scamming" (dishonest), "mong" (unintelligent) etc. have been doing the rounds depicting Hindus as dirty, Islamophobic and barbaric.[19]
Locally in East Leicester, a large batch of Hindu immigrants belonging to Daman and Diu,[note 1] carrying Portuguese passports, are said to have arrived in Leicester in the recent years, before Brexit. They settled in the LE5 postcode area, which was otherwise predominantly Muslim.[20][21][note 2] The celebration of Hindu festivals and public consumption of alcohol by the new arrivals were considered disruptive by Muslims living in the area.[23] Leicester East MP Claudia Webbe stated that friction between the two communities had been "simmering for months".[24]
At least one major incident of communitarian violence has been reported from May, where it was alleged that a Muslim man was surrounded by around 25–30 masked men, and beaten with bats and poles to such an extent that he was hospitalised. The incident was reported to the police, but the Muslim community felt that the police were failing to act, with the result that the perpetrators were still at large and continuing to harass the Muslim community. The Muslim community labelled these perpetrators "Hindutva RSS thugs" and believed that they were from among the recent arrivals from India.[25][26][note 3] According to Majid Freeman, a self described "former aid worker and a key social media influencer", who has been previously known to make false allegations of Quran burning[28] and for supporting the terrorist group ISIL [29] on online forums, "Muslims had made their presence known in the streets" by August and the "troublemakers had disappeared".[30]
After the 28 August India–Pakistan Asia Cup cricket match, which India won, Indian cricket fans poured onto streets in the Belgrave area to celebrate, waving Indian flags, honking car horns and dancing to dhols. An altercation eventually occurred at the corner of the Shaftsbury Avenue and Melton road. According to a local business owner, "someone anti-India" stamped on an Indian flag, and the Indian fans thought he was a Pakistani and got infuriated.[31] A video of this incident is available and the man is reported to be a Sikh.[32] The altercation developed into a brawl, a video clip of which went viral on social media the next day. The clip shows a group of India fans shouting "Pakistan murdabad"[note 4] and walking to the clash site. A police officer is seen arresting a man, and another group is seen beating up a man, and ripping off his t-shirt.[32]
The incident eventually led to eight arrests, including one man arrested at the scene for assaulting an emergency worker.[36]
The following day a twitter user with handle "tragicBud", whose user description included the phrase “fuck them pajeets” (anti-Hindu slur), uploaded the video clip of the brawl, along with an interpretation claiming "Nazi" and "Hindutva" objectives of the participants. This was the beginning of "malicious narratives", as the NCRI researchers described it, interpreting an ordinary cricket match brawl as a "Nazi-like Hindutva" ideology. It led to a steady escalation of tensions in Leicester.[32] A slogan of "death to Muslims" was also alleged to have been raised, but the Leicester police dismissed the claim, not finding any verifiable evidence for it.[37][38]
The video clip uploaded by "tragicBud" was widely shared on social media networks, amplified by Majid Freeman, Ian Miles Cheong, Sunny Hundal, Pat McGinnes and several British conservative participants.[37] Sunny Hundal's forwarding comment, "extreme Hindutva groups go on the rampage in Leicester", gave journalistic respectability to the anti-Hindutva narrative.[31] The Muslim news site "5Pillars UK" announced that Muslim residents of Leicester were being attacked. British comedian Guz Khan, with 100,000 followers on twitter, called on "mandem" (UK slang for "gang") to sort out the "Modi weirdos".[37] Other reputed organisations that address Islamophobic incidents also joined in, interpreting the video clip as representing Islamophobia. The original tweet of tragicBud received 2,037 retweets and the video clip 305,000 views.[32][note 5]
Between 4-6 September, anti-Hindu attacks began to be reported from Leicester. On 4 September, the date of another India–Pakistan match which Pakistan won, a Hindu home celebrating Ganesh Chaturthi (a Hindu religious festival) was allegedly attacked, eggs were thrown into the house, a Hindu male was attempted to be stabbed, and his aunt was punched in the nose.[42][43][note 6] The next day, there were report of British Pakistani mobs targeting Hindu neighbourhoods, some with weapons, chanting "Modi kutta, Hindustan murdabad" ("Modi dog, Death to India").[42] Videos circulated of gangs roaming through the streets and police trying to block them. Hindus started feeling scared in their homes and writing to the local MPs for help.[45][35]
On 5 September, there was a meeting about the incidents attended by over 300 people along with police representatives. After the meeting, a group of Muslims conducted a march through Leicester to show their "presence". It was reported that clashes and stand-offs with the police lasted till 11 pm.[44]
On 6 September, Leicester Police were authorised to use dispersal (Sections 34 and 35) and stop-and-search (Section 60) powers.[46] They continued to patrol the areas, but further disturbances also continued.[35]
By 11 September, 19 people had been arrested for incidents in East Leicester, one of them for threats to kill.[36]
The Muslim social media accounts continued to propagate misinformation and the branding of Leicester Hindus as "RSS Hindutva thugs". A Muslim author Riaz Khan, with 25,000 followers, linked the incident from May to the cricket match brawl and described the participants of the latter as the same "thugs".[26] Another user with 600,000 subscribers, advised the India fans in the UK to "humble themselves" because the Pakistani gangs over here "go a bit nuts".[26] The most virulent misinformation came from Majid Freeman, who claimed that there was a kidnap attempt of a Muslim school girl by three Hindu men. He claimed that he had spoken to the girl's family and that the police had "confirmed" it.[47] Leicester city police denied the claim quite emphatically.[48] But the misinformation continued to circulate on social media.[49] Also related was a Majid Freeman post, showing the picture of a man standing in front of a car, and claiming that he was an "RSS man" targeting Muslims, Sikhs, women and children.[49]
A British Pakistani influencer called "Dutch Raja" (Norman Khan from Birmingham),[3] who had 150,000 followers, posted the picture along with a poll asking, "Shall we go Saturday [to] teach these guys a lesson?"; 95% of the respondents voted yes. Thus, Saturday the 17th April was set as the date for Muslim mobilisation.[50][51]
The Hindus in East Leicester that were targeted as "RSS or BJP" men started fearing for their well-being. Some temporarily relocated to other locations; others refrained from venturing out for fear of being attacked. Some reported receiving stab wounds from the attacks during 4–6 September. One victim's mother told a TV reporter that she had experienced better Hindu–Muslim relations in Daman and Diu in India than she was finding in Leicester.[51][52]
The weekend 17–19 September, which was reserved for the funeral of Queen Elizabeth II, witnessed a large number of incidents which were described by the British press as "violent disorder".[53]
Saturday, 17 September, began with a peace march organised by Hindus to show solidarity with the victims of the violence in the preceding weeks. The march began on Belgrave Road (which continues on to Melton Road) and followed on to Green Lane Road in East Leicester. The march is said to have been conducted on foot paths, and was overseen by the local police.[54] Despite it being a supervised march, Muslims in East Leicester said they were intimidated and felt threatened.[55][56] Three slogans were reportedly used by the protesters, Jai Shri Ram, Ganapati Bappa Moriya, and Vande Mataram,[57] of which only Jai Shri Ram was mentioned by the mainstream press.[58][59]
According to the police, a second "unplanned protest" was formed after this, by "groups of young men" (apparently Hindus, numbering about 200), proceeding towards Highfields.[60] According to Leicester Mercury, "an opposing group also gathered".[61] Police said it numbered 600–700 men (apparently Muslims). The police scrambled about 100 officers to keep the two groups apart.[62] Both the sides shouted slogans, with the Hindus shouting Jai Shri Ram and Vande Mataram, and the Muslims shouting "Allah-o-Akbar".[63][64] Social media influencers as well as the mainstream press referenced only the Hindu protesters and emphasised "Jai Shri Ram" as possible evidence of Hindutva extremism.[65][66][67][68]
According to The Times of India, the trigger for these events was a poster created in Birmingham (following on from the fake news of kidnap and Dutch Raja's post), calling on Birmingham Muslims to participate in a protest in Leicester.[69] The Hindus were angered by the poster as well as the fake social media claims regarding a kidnapping attempt by Hindu youth. They marched down the Belgrave Road in protest.[63] The two sides faced off somewhere on Belgrave Road, with the police trying to keep them apart.[63] The police issued a dispersal order at some point, which caused the crowds to move to other locations. A number of breakout incidents then occurred, continuing through the night, with calm being restored only the next morning.[70][53] The most significant event of that night was the pulling down of a saffron flag from the wall of Shivalaya (Shiva temple) on Belgrave Road and an attempt to burn it.[63] According to a Hindu community leader, further desecration was blocked by an imam that stood guard.[71] The police said that 16 police officers and a dog were injured during the events of that night.[72][73]
On Sunday, 18 September, the police got ready for handling further disturbances by recalling officers from Queen's funeral duties in London.[74] An unauthorised protest was held by Muslims on this day, which is said to have been widely advertised on WhatsApp.[75] Police oversaw the march, which apparently concluded without any incident.[76] An Islamist preacher named Mohammed Hijab from London arrived in Leicester. He posted videos of himself inciting Muslims with anti-Hindu rhetoric and asking them to retaliate. The men agreed and chanted "Allah-o-Akbar".[77] According to reports, the police dispersed their march, but once again, disorder broke out at other locations, this time in North Evington.[75] Police put in place a temporary police cordon and arrested 15 people.[61][76]
On the whole, 47 people were arrested since the beginning of 28 August. Of these 11 people were reported to be from outside Leicester, one from Market Harborough, eight from Birmingham and two from London.[48] The mayor of Leicester Sir Peter Soulsby said that the unrest was "fanned by some very distorted social media" and "a lot of people who came in from outside".[78][79]
Misinformation continued to flow on social media even during the weekend. One rumour said that Hindus had attacked a mosque. Despite the police debunking the claim, it continued to circulate on social media.[80] Another said that the Hindu temple in Ealing Road (London) arranged a bus from Angel Tours to transport Hindutva RSS members to Leicester to mobilise violence against Muslims.[81][48] The claim was debunked by a journalist of The Guardian.[82] Analysts also found anti-Muslim disinformation during the weekend, in particular a claim that a Hindu temple in Birmingham was burnt down, using images of an unrelated event.[83][48]
Tensions continued into the following week, with the unrest spreading from Leicester to the Birmingham area on Tuesday 20 September. Video footage showed nearly 200 Muslim men surrounding the Durga Bhawan Temple in Smethwick, a neighbourhood where almost one-in-four residents are Asian, chanting 'Allahu Akbar'. They were voicing their anger at the temple for inviting a controversial Hindutva proponent, Sadhvi Rithambara, as a guest speaker.[84] One video showed a masked man with a Birmingham accent say "RSS speakers are not welcome in Birmingham, not welcome anywhere in the UK. None of your speakers, any of the hate speakers, we are going to turn up for all of them...we've got no issues with British Hindus, we grew up with them, we know all of them. But RSS, you'll be met by us every single time".[85]
The surge in violence took many by surprise, and senior representatives of Leicester's Muslim and Hindu communities urged calm. On Tuesday 20 September, President of the ISKCON Leicester Hindu Temple, Pradip Gajjar, said he was "saddened and heartbroken to see the eruption of tension and violence."[86]
Labour MP Jonathan Ashworth critiqued the events as "shocking scenes of unacceptable incidents of violence," and that all "are united in calling for calm, peace and harmony."
Leicester East MP Claudia Webbe has called for cooler heads to prevail, urging strengthened "dialogue to repair community relations", while warning the violence "has the potential to spread to other areas...and has the potential to spread across the country".[87]
Rob Nixon, Acting Chief Police Constable for Leicestershire, has noted the investigation into the unrest will run for "several months" and that "the traditional community leaders, partners […] having a really detailed dialogue about some of these tensions, how we've got to where we are, and how we resolve them and take the issues forward."
The Network Contagion Research Institute (NCRI) associated with the Rutgers University analysed the social media traffic during the clashes and reported that malicious narratives played an essential role in instigating the attacks.[88]
A report commissioned by the Henry Jackson Society, which has been critiqued as having an anti-Muslim agenda along with being regarded as a British neo-conservative think tank, claimed that the social media instigators were "Islamist radicals". It named the alleged influencers and provided their background.[89][90][91][92][93][94]
Delhi-based Centre for Democracy, Pluralism and Human Rights (CDPHR) produced a fact-finding report and zeroed in on the issue of "ethnic enclaves" in Leicester. It said that different religious groups were living in ethnic enclaves, with some ethnicities more "clubbed up" in some spaces more than others. The report claims that the ethnic enclaves gave rise to territorial tensions and localised majoritarianism. Their report was launched in the UK House of Commons.[95]
On 22 September, the mayor of Leicester, Sir Peter Soulsby, announced an independent review into the events of the unrest, which he said would be completed "within weeks".[96] A month later Chris AllenofUniversity of Leicester was named to head the review. The appointment was criticised by multiple groups, and the Hindu groups of Leicester said they would boycott the reivew.[97] Allen then declined to undertake the role.[98]
In May 2023, the UK government announced the formation of a panel for independent review headed by former Labour Party MP, Lord Ian Austin.[99] The other panel members are Samir Shah, a former commissioner for the Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities, Hilary Pilkington of the University of Manchester, a Fellow of the UK Academy of Social Sciences, and Shaaz Mahboob of NHS England, a trustee of British Muslims for Secular Democracy.[100] Concerns have also been raised regarding the choice of Lord Austin.[101] Lord Austin responded by stating that he was coming to the review with a completely open mind and that he genuinely wanted to help.[102] A call for submissions of evidence was issued in May 2024.[103]
Leicestershire Police continued investigations into the events of the unrest, employing a team of 50 officers. More than 100 incidents and 6,000 hours of video footage from body-worn cameras, CCTV and phone were investigated.[104] A total of 73 people were detained by November 2022.[105][106] As of September 2023[update], 32 people were convicted of offences including affray, threats to kill, racial or religious public order crimes and possession of weapons. 19 cases were still pending.[104] Majid Freeman, who was repeatedly found to be spreading misinformation that instigated the violence, was convicted in June 2024 under section 4 of the Public Order Act 1986.[107][note 7] In July, he was arrested and charged with "encouragement of terrorism and supporting a proscibed organisation" in unrelated incidents.[109] According to 5Pillars UK, the organisation is the Palestinian organisation Hamas.[110]
In the run-up to the 2023 Leicester City Council election, the Labour Party "deselected" a large number of its councillors, i.e., they would not get a Labour Party ticket for the election. The deselected councillors included 15 out of 26 councillors belonging to the Black, Asian or minority ethnic (BAME) communities. All of the Hindu councillors were deselected.[111][112] These councillors either joined the Conservative Party or decided to run as independents. Through the election, the Labour Party saw its strength drop from 53 seats to 31 seats. The Conservative Party won 17 seats, up from 2 seats earlier. All three seats in Belgrave and three seats in North Evington went to the Conservatives.[113]
The Mayor's handling of the 2022 unrest was cited by many as the reason for these developments. According to one of the deselected councillors, Hindus and Muslims lost trust in the mayor Peter Soulsby, and all those that challenged his handling were deselected.[112] There were also moves to remove the elected mayoral model that had been in operation for 12 years, even though it was unsuccessful.[114][115]
In the July 2024 general election, the Conservatives again won the East Leicester seat for the Parliament, electing a new MP, Shivani Raja.[116]
On [6 September], an emergency meeting was held between representatives of Leicester's Hindu and Muslim communities. Since then, police patrols have continued in the areas affected, but further disturbances are still being reported.
In one video a PIO [Indian origin] family can be heard terrified in their homes watching the violence from their window as they take a video of the gangs wandering around parked cars shouting with weapons in hand. ... Members of the PIO community are now writing to their local MPs expressing concern.
Rukhsana Hussain, 42, a community leader, described hearing loud chants of "Jai Shri Ram", which translates from Hindi as "hail Lord Ram" or "victory to Lord Ram", from several streets away. This traditional Hindu greeting or chant has increasingly been appropriated by perpetrators of anti-Muslim violence in India, whose prime minister, Narendra Modi, is under growing scrutiny for the treatment of minorities, including Muslims. [Footnote:] This article was amended on 20 September 2022 to distinguish between the routine use of "Jai Shri Ram" for a greeting or religious observance, and its adoption by perpetrators of anti-Muslim violence in India.
On Saturday a large group of Hindu men protested in the city, with some shouting 'Jai Shri Ram' – a slogan which has increasingly been used by Hindu nationalists in India.
On Saturday a large group of Hindu men protested in the city, with some shouting 'Jai Shri Ram' – a slogan which has increasingly been used by Hindu nationalists in India.
["Jai Shri Ram"] is a chant that has recently become synonymous with anti-Muslim violence in India, where India's prime minister, Narendra Modi, is under increasing scrutiny for the treatment of minorities, including Muslims in the country.
