The building which housed the Arch Street Theatre was located between 6th and 7th Streets at 819 Arch Street. Performers at the venue included Fanny Davenport, Joseph Jefferson, and Charlotte Cushman, others.[3]John Wilkes Booth joined the theatre's stock company in 1857 and played for a full season. He appeared occasionally at the Arch during the 1850s and early 1860s.[4]
In the 1830s, Edwin Forrest played many successful roles at the Arch, and several original plays written at his request debuted there.[5]
In 1832, the Arch Street Theatre had an entire company of American actors, which was a first for American theater companies.[6] The managers were William Forrest, William Duffy, and William Jones.[7] The company included James E. Murdoch.[6]
In 1860, the stockholders of the Arch suggested that Louisa Lane Drew should assume the management, and in 1861 the theatre was opened under the name "Mrs. John Drew's Arch Street Theatre". Louisa Lane Drew was the grandmother of Lionel, Ethel and John Barrymore.[8] During the third season under Drew's management, Lester Wallack, E. L. Davenport, and Edwin Booth acted at the Arch.[9]
In the summer of 1863, the theatre was pulled down and rebuilt with red plush seats and crystal chandeliers from the stage to the façade;[9] the seating capacity was one thousand, nine-hundred eleven.[10]
In 1875, the theatre became the venue for the first performance of a work by Gilbert and Sullivan in America when Alice Oates staged an unauthorised and approximate performance of Trial by Jury here.[11]
After Drew's departure in 1892, the stature of the Arch Street Theatre slowly declined.[2] In 1898 Morris Finkel rented the building and presented Yiddish theater for several months, including one week of performances by Keni Liptzin. The prolific Yiddish theatre composer Joseph Brody, recently arrived from Russia, got his American start there as well.[12] However, Finkel soon abandoned the project and the Arch returned to vaudeville.
