Smith wrote for the news outlet Politico from 2008 to 2011, joining as that site expanded. Joining Politico from the New York Daily News in 2007, Smith covered the Democratic presidential primary for Politico in 2008. He covered controversies including Barack Obama's contacts with former WeathermanBill Ayers[11] and conspiracy theories about Obama's citizenship[12] and Barack Obama religion conspiracy theories.[13] Smith reported erroneously during that 2008 campaign that John Edwards would be dropping out of the race[14] before the press conference at which Edwards announced that his wife Elizabeth had cancer. Smith later posted an apology[15] and retracted the story. In 2010, he reported on a confidential Republican National Committee fundraising presentation counseling the party to capitalize on fear.[16]
In December 2011, he was named editor-in-chief of BuzzFeed News.[2] Smith explained that he would be leaving his Politico blog but he would still write for the publication weekly.[17] While working at BuzzFeed, Smith focused on strengthening the organization's investigative journalism unit.[18][19]
Smith interviewed Barack Obama in early 2015 for BuzzFeed's first presidential interview.[20]
In January 2017, Smith, as the editor of BuzzFeed News, published the Steele dossier, a 35-page dossier about Donald Trump, which major news organizations, including The New York Times and NBC News, refused to publish due to lack of credible evidence. Smith defended his decision by saying, "We have always erred on the side of publishing."[21]
On May 17, 2020, Smith published an article titled "Is Ronan Farrow Too Good to Be True?" arguing that some of Farrow's journalism did not hold up to scrutiny.[23] In response, Farrow said that he stood by his reporting.[24] In a Slate piece, Ashley Feinberg described Smith's report as an "overcorrection for resistance journalism" and opined that his approach showed "broad-mindedness, sacrificing accuracy for some vague, centrist perception of fairness."[25]
Smith reported in late September 2021 that Ozy, a media company, had attempted to deceive investors and advertisers. After Smith's media column appeared on September 26, the story led to a flurry of additional investigation and reporting by multiple sources including Smith, culminating in Ozy's board of directors announcing their intention to shut the company down on October 1.[26]
In early January 2022, Smith announced he would be leaving The New York Times to start a global news venture aimed at the 200 million college-educated English readers. Justin B. Smith would lead the business side of the new venture and Ben would be the top editor. The news site says it will break news and offer nuance to complex news stories.[27] Justin Smith described a new company that would "reimagine quality global journalism" aimed at what he said was an "English-speaking, college-educated, professional class" that had "lost trust in all sources of news and information."[28] The name of the new venture, Semafor, was announced in March 2022.[29]
^"The Axe Files - Ep. 136: Ben Smith Released"(PDF). University of Chicago Institute of Politics and CNN. April 6, 2017. Archived from the original(PDF) on January 21, 2019. I grew up in a household where my parents disagreed on pretty much everything and it makes it hard for you to be a real ideologue or to sort of -- you know, or to see the opposing side. To see these two sides is irreconcilable enemies. She's a Democrat and he's also fairly Christian. She's Jewish.