Following three years at Dens Park, he moved to Hibernian with Lee Power for a combined fee of £200,000.[2] However, Jim Duffy, who had signed Tosh, was soon fired from his position as manager.[2] After struggling to get into the first team under Alex McLeish, he was sent out on loan to Partick Thistle and then Exeter City, before he moved to Raith Rovers.[2] Paul scored 13 goals over his two seasons there but was released by the Kirkcaldy outfit.
A former Second Division player of the year,[3] Tosh's consistent ability to score goals saw "Tosher" rack up nearly 90 goals in Forfar colours, averaging slightly better than a goal every other game. Tosh was player-assistant manager during the reign of former Forfar manager George Shaw. After only one match being caretaker manager he left on emergency loan to local rivals and his hometown team Arbroath in 2007. He returned to Arbroath in July 2007 and continued his scoring into season 2007–08.
Paul started working in the Construction Industry after his football career, notably spending time with Hillcrest Housing Association and Persimmon Homes North Scotland [5]
