 | This is a failed proposal. Consensus for its implementation was not established within a reasonable period of time. If you want to revive discussion, please use the talk page or initiate a thread at the village pump. |
There is great admiration for Mr Wales's co-creation of one of the world's most significant information resources, and for the basic design features he has insisted on; however, most of his work in those respects is done. While Mr Wales can be proud of his achievement and will almost certainly continue to play a role in the English Wikipedia and the Wikimedia Foundation for as long as he wishes, the time has come to recast his relationship with the project. His leading role was helpful when the project was young and innocent, but the English Wikipedia has matured: it is now too large and powerful not to have a modern system of governance.
It is hoped that Mr Wales will continue to be recognised as "the special Wikipedian" and to give his expertise to the project and its public relations. However, there is clearly a mood for constitutional change. Modernising the relationship between Mr Wales and the English Wikipedia's "Supreme Court"—the Arbitration Committee (ArbCom)—will be an historic and critical step. It will bring the project closer to the governance systems of the other Wikipedias, such as the German and the French, which have a relationship with Mr Wales only insofar as his membership of the Board of the Wikimedia Foundation.
This RFC is a carefully conceived, minimalist proposal, in which we seek to determine whether there is community consensus to:
We encourage discussion of the issues raised, beneath the RFC on the talk page.
The changes involve two sections of the draft updated ArbCom policy that ArbCom released on June 26 for community feedback: (1) Selection and appointment and (2) Appeals of decisions. The struck-through text is removed; the normal text is added.
1.
The members of the Committee are appointed by Jimbo Wales, in his role as project leader, following annual advisory elections, whose format is decided by the community.
Starting December 2009, new members of the Committee will be elected each December to bring the total number of members to 17.
2.
Remedies and enforcement actions by the Arbitration Committee may be appealed to, and are subject to modification by, Jimbo Wales, except where the case involves review of one of Jimbo Wales's own actions.
