Jump to content
 







Main menu
    


Navigation  


●Main page
 ●Contents
 ●Current events
 ●Random article
 ●About Wikipedia
 ●Contact us
 ●Donate
  



Contribute  


●Help
 ●Learn to edit
 ●Community portal
 ●Recent changes
 ●Upload file
  







Search  

































●Create account

●Log in
 









●Create account
 ● Log in
  



Pages for logged out editors learn more  


●Contributions
 ●Talk
  


















Contents

   



(Top)
  


1 Prior to 2014  




2 2014  




3 2015  




4 2016  




5 2017  




6 2018  




7 2019  




8 2020  




9 2021  













Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Closure review archive







Add links
  








●Project page
 ●Talk
  
















●Read
 ●Edit
 ●View history
  







Tools
    


Actions  


●Read
 ●Edit
 ●View history
  



General  


●What links here
 ●Related changes
 ●Upload file
 ●Special pages
 ●Permanent link
 ●Page information
 ●Get shortened URL
 ●Download QR code
  



Print/export  


●Download as PDF
 ●Printable version
  















Appearance
    

 





From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  
< Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard

This page is for archiving closure reviews listed at Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard:

Prior to 2014[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive228#RFC close review: Category:Anti-abortion violence 23 October 2011 Category talk:Anti-abortion violence#RFC on supercategory [1] Reopened
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive242#Richard Tylman and the case of the uncloseable RFC 5 December 2012 Talk:Richard Tylman/Archive 1#RfC: Should information sourced to research in genealogical websites be included? [2] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive772#Would an uninvolved admin please endorse or overturn the RfC closure? 13 October 2013 Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Archive 131#RfC: Internal consistency versus consistency across articles [3] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive241#Review of RFC closure 17 November 2012 Wikipedia talk:Biographies of living persons/Archive 35#Misuse of primary sources [4] Closer changed close to no consensus
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive248#Closure review of Simple English proposal at Village Pump 17 April 2013 Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)/Archive 99#Simple English at top of languages [5] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive253#Request closure review 12 September 2013 Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Music/Archive 7#Names (definite article) [6] Closer self-reverted
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive254#RfC validity review requested 8 October 2013 Talk:Ayn Rand/Archive 47#Request for comment: Qualifying "philosopher" in the lead sentence [7] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive255#WP:Archive.is RFC request for admin review of closure 31 October 2013 Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Archive.is RFC [8] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive255#Request for closure review 1 November 2013 Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Archive 148#RfC on pronouns throughout life [9] Closer self-reverted
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result

2014[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive258#Closure review request 18 January 2014 Talk:United States/Archive 60#Inequality, tax incidence, and AP survey [10] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive260#Reverting merge about the short-lived independence of Crimea as a country 23 March 2014 Talk:Republic of Crimea/Archive 1#Proposal to merge article titled "Republic of Crimea (country)" into this article [11] New RfC permitted
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive260#RFC closure review 26 March 2014 Talk:Chris Christie/Archive 1#RfC: Is information about the actions of Christie administration officials appropriate for the article? [12] No consensus due to low participation
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive260#RfC closure review: Mr Whoppit 7 April 2014 Talk:Mr Whoppit#Request for comment [13] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive260#Unexplainable non-admin RfC closing and edit warring 16 April 2014 Talk:List of countries where Arabic is an official language#Palestinian Authority [14] Alternative offered and agreed upon to be picked up at the talk page
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive263#Requesting closure review of Stefan Molyneux RfC 27 June 2014 Talk:Stefan Molyneux/Archive 2#RfC - Should Stefan Molyneux be described as a "philosopher" in the lede? [15] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive263#RfC closure review: Coat of arms of Mauritius 28 June 2014 Talk:Coat of arms of Mauritius#RfC: Which coat of arms should be used? [16] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive263#Review of RfC close requested (Progressive tax) 1 July 2014 Talk:Progressive tax/Archive 4#RfC on what to include about progressiveness of US tax system [17] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive263#Closure of RfC: Should Tesla's birthplace be changed? 6 July 2014 Talk:Nikola Tesla/Nationality and ethnicity/Archive 3#RfC: Should Tesla's birthplace be changed? [18] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive264#RFC closure review 24 July 2014 Talk:John Anthony Brooks#Request for Comment [19] No consensus, close allowed to stand by default
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive264#Closure review 20 August 2014 Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive264#Excessive topic-ban [20] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive264#Review of Admin RFC Closure (removal of book by Koenraad Elst in Further reading section of an article) 26 August 2014 Talk:Bharatiya Janata Party/Archive 4#RfC: Can this book(BJP vis-a-vis Hindu Resurgence) on BJP by Koenraad Elst be added to further reading section of BJP article or is this book considered fringe theory? [21] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive264#RfC close review please? 28 August 2014 Talk:Opinion polling for the 2015 United Kingdom general election/Archives/2014/August#RfC: Should the Green Party, along with other parties be included in the table of polling results [22] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive264#Move War at History of the Jews in Nepal, and RFC review 11 September 2014 Talk:Judaism in Nepal#RfC: Should we change article name to 'Judaism in Nepal'? [23] Endorsed, reinstate valid RfC outcome
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive265#AfD/IAR review 2 October 2014 Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/After Saturday Comes Sunday (2nd nomination) [24] No consensus
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive860#Close of a stale RFC 20 October 2014 Talk:Ebola virus cases in the United States/Archive 6#RfC [25] Reclosed by uninvolved admin
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive267#RFC close review Talk:2014 Iranian-led intervention in Iraq#Iran, Hezbollah Reaction to American-led intervention in Iraq 8 November 2014 Talk:2014 Iranian-led intervention in Iraq/Archive 1#Iran, Hezbollah Reaction to American-led intervention in Iraq [26] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive267#Closure review: America: Imagine the World Without Her 10 November 2014 Talk:America: Imagine the World Without Her/Archive 4#RFC - Is Breitbart.com a reliable source for its own film review? [27] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive266#Close Review Media Viewer RfC 15 November 2014 Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)/Archive 116#Media Viewer RfC Question 1 [28] Closer commented out close
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive268#Close Review Request after overturn and reclose 17 December 2014 Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)/Media viewer 2014#Media Viewer RfC Question 1 and Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)/Media viewer 2014#Media Viewer RfC Question 2 [29] and [30] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive267#Restoring reverted close of Talk:Cultural Marxism#Re-proposal 21 December 2014 Talk:Cultural Marxism/Archive 3#Merger with "Frankfurt School Conspiracy Theory" – discussion 2 [31] Endorsed by uninvolved admin
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive267#Closure Review Request on Climate Engineering 29 December 2014 Talk:Climate engineering/Archive 2#Editing disagreement over soot particles [32] Endorsed
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result

2015[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive267#Close review please 2 January 2015 Template talk:Infobox person/Archive 25#RfC: Proposed addition of pronunciations to infobox person [33] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive268#Closure Review Request at Talk: Ayurveda#Objection to improper closure 11 January 2015 Talk:Ayurveda/Archive 9#Should this article be categorized as "pseudoscience"? [34] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive270#Review of Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2015 January 8#Kirby Delauter and Draft:Kirby Delauter 18 January 2015 Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2015 January 8#Kirby Delauter [35] Reinstating the salting is not an enforceable provision of the DRV close
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Review of the Closing for a WP:RFC for America: Imagine the World Without Her 24 January 2015 Talk:America: Imagine the World Without Her/Archive 7#RfC: Is Breitbart.com a reliable source for the opinion of Ben Shapiro [36] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive268#Review Closure of debate : Proposed Hypothesis/Theory as fact 27 January 2015 Wikipedia:Fringe theories/Noticeboard/Archive 45#Proposed Hypothesis/Theory as fact [37] Overturned as premature
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive268#Reviewing RfC closure : Battle of Chawinda 28 January 2015 Talk:Battle of Chawinda/Archive 1#DID the battle lead to Major Pakistani victory? [38] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Requesting review of close of RfC at Griffin article 4 February 2015 Talk:G. Edward Griffin/Archive 7#RfC: "conspiracy theorist" in first sentence [39] No consensus to overturn, further discussion recommended
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Request for review of closure at AN/I 8 February 2015 Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive872#Conduct of J Doug McLean [40] Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive270#Review of non-admin closure at Manual of Style/Icons 11 February 2015 Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Icons/Archive 14#Formula 1 [41] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Closure review: Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/RfC to physically restrict access to the Helper Script 18 February 2015 Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/RfC to physically restrict access to the Helper Script [42] Overturned
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Requesting review of close of RfC at Template talk:Infobox officeholder#RfC Congressmen's tenures in infobox 27 February 2015 Template talk:Infobox officeholder/Archive 19#RfC Congressmen's tenures in infobox [43] Withdrawn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive270#Closure Review Request at MOS page 5 March 2015 Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Biographies/2015 archive#RfC: Comma or no comma before Jr. and Sr. [44] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Review request for non-admin closure at WT:NCF 10 March 2015 Wikipedia talk:Naming conventions (films)/Archive 2#RFC: Series subject as a name [45] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Closure review 18 March 2015 Wikipedia talk:Protection policy/Archive 15#Own userspace pages protection policy [46] Rationale amended
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive271#Request for review of close at Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Capital letters#Request for comment - Capitalise universe 24 April 2015 Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Capital letters/Archive 18#Request for comment - Capitalise universe [47] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive271#Request for review of RfC closed at Talk:Project for the New American Century 5 May 2015 Talk:Project for the New American Century/Archive 5#RfC [48] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive271#Review non-admin close of RFC 20 May 2015 Wikipedia talk:Conflict of interest/Archive 20#RfC on COI for alt-med practitioners [49] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive272#RFC Review at Talk:Ayurveda/Archive 9 4 June 2015 Talk:Ayurveda/Archive 9#Should this article be categorized as "pseudoscience"? [50] RfC close retracted due to extensive sockpuppetry; new RfC started
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive272#RFC closure challenge 19 June 2015 Talk:Dennis Hastert/Archive 1#RfC: Should the lead mention that there were allegations of sexual abuse? [51] Overturned
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive272#Where is Poland? 23 June 2015 Talk:Poland/Archive 6#RfC: Eastern vs. Central Europe [52] Closer self-reverted
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive273#Closure Review 26 June 2015 Talk:Grand Theft Auto V/Archive 3#Merger proposal [53] Overturned to merge
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive891#RFC Close for Ayurveda 7 July 2015 Talk:Ayurveda/Archive 12#Category:Pseudoscience [54] RfC close reverted and RfC reclosed by uninvolved admin
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive274#RfC closure review: Talk:Kosovo#Request for comment 10 August 2015 Talk:Kosovo/Archive 31#Request for comment [55] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive274#RfC closure challenge: Template talk:Cite doi#RfC: Should Template:cite doi cease creating a separate subpage for each DOI? 8 September 2015 Template talk:Cite doi/Archive 1#RfC: Should Template:cite doi cease creating a separate subpage for each DOI? [56] Newer RfC will decide the matter
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive274#Request closure review for RfC at Monsanto Legal Cases 22 September 2015 Talk:Monsanto legal cases/Archive 3#RfC: Should this article mention current lawsuits by U.S. cities against Monsanto? [57] Withdrawn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive275#Request for RFC close review 17 October 2015 Talk:Serbs of Croatia/Archive 9#Serbs as "constitutive" nation in Socialist Republic of Croatia [58] Closure left as is
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive276#Challenge closure on Climate change denial talk page 10 November 2015 Talk:Climate change denial/Archive 31#Redirects to this page [59] Third closing statement by an uninvolved admin added that does not change the result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive277#Closure review at Talk:Martha Jefferson 3 December 2015 Talk:Martha Jefferson#Restored article [60] Endorsed
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result

2016[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive277#Request close review of RFC - Remove Flow from WikiProject Breakfast? 9 January 2016 Topic:Stn15z0u230zcbve [61] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive278#RFC review request: Request for Comment: Country of Origin 20 January 2016 Wikipedia talk:Identifying reliable sources (medicine)/Archive 19#Request for Comment: Country of Origin [62] Overturned
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive278#RfC close review please? 16 February 2016 Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Images/Archive 6#"Articles about ethnic groups or similarly large human populations should not be illustrated by a gallery of images of group members" [63] Closer amended close
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive278#RfC close review request: Jeremy Corbyn, place of birth 16 February 2016 Talk:Jeremy Corbyn/Archive 6#RfC: for place of birth in the infobox -- England or UK? [64] Overturned to no consensus
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive917#Application of WP:ROUGHCONSENSUS 17 March 2016 Talk:Maya civilization#RfC: Definition [65] Closer reversed close and reclosed by uninvolved admin
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive280#A recent AN/I close 8 April 2016 Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive919#Godsy Disruption & GAMING the System [66] Endorsed; rationale amended
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive281#WP:CLOSECHALLENGE: Should this closure be overturned? 19 June 2016 Wikipedia:Village pump (policy)/Archive 128#RfC: Wikidata in infoboxes, opt-in or opt-out? [67] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive282#Review of Wikipedia talk:Redirects for discussion#Allow non-admin delete closures? 9 July 2016 Wikipedia talk:Redirects for discussion/Archive 9#RfC: Allow non-admins to close RfD discussions to "delete"? [68] Close reverted and discussion reopened and reclosed as no consensus
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive282#RfC close review please 25 July 2016 Talk:Isaac Barrow#Allegations by Fountains of Bryn Mawr [69] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive283#Review of RfC on the classification of Jews on Template talk:Ethnic slurs 8 August 2016 Template talk:Ethnic slurs/Archive 1#RFC: Should Jews be classified as Asian, European, or in a standalone category? [70] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive285#Request for re-close of an old RfC (and closure of a disruptive RfC) 26 August 2016 Talk:Paul Singer (businessman)/Archive 6#RfC: Vulture [71] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive283#Overdue RFC closure review 29 August 2016 Talk:Noël Coward/Archive 2#RfC: Should an Infobox be added to the page? [72] Reopened the 1st, closed the 2nd
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive283#Closure review requested: Trump 2 September 2016 Talk:Donald Trump/Archive 26#RfC: Donald Trump's false campaign statements [73] Closer self-reverted
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive283#Request for closure review on unseen character talk page: "Request For Comments - examples that Wikipedia editors don't believe qualify" 7 September 2016 Talk:Unseen character/Archive 1#Request For Comments - examples that Wikipedia editors don't believe qualify [74] Closure reverted, then closed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive283#Request for review of close on WP:ANI 14 September 2016 Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive933#Gross incivility and edit war from Engleham [75] Reopened
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive285#Request for Closure Review: Talk:Michael Portillo#RfC: Should predecessors and successors be included in the infobox? 3 December 2016 Talk:Michael Portillo/Archive 1#RfC: Should predecessors and successors be included in the infobox? [76] Moot; another RfC created
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive286#Request for review of Wurdi Youang RFC closure 6 December 2016 Talk:Wurdi Youang#RfC: should the coordinates be included in the article [77] No consensus to overturn no consensus close, restore stable version containing coordinates
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive286#IP editor votes in RfC and closes it 27 December 2016 Talk:North Korea/Archive 16#Should we use juche in the infobox? [78] Reopened
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive286#Request review of non-admin closure of RFC 31 December 2016 Talk:Disputed status of Gibraltar/Archive 7#Request for Comment - Article Rewrite [79] Reopened
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result

2017[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive286#RFC close review at Talk:Silicon Alley#RfC: Should this article discuss the biotech industry 20 January 2017 Talk:Silicon Alley/Archive 1#RfC: Should this article discuss the biotech industry? [80],[81] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive287#Review of an improper RfC closure 27 January 2017 Wikipedia talk:Copyrights/Archive 15#RfC: Hosting content from countries that do not have copyright relations with the U.S. [82][83] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive947#Overturn Rfc restarted 25 February 2017 Category talk:People of Jewish descent/Archive 2#Survey [84],[85] Reclosed as no consensus
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive287#RfC close review please? 6 March 2017 Talk:United States presidential election, 2016/Archive 22#RFC on including Russian influence into the election [86] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive289#Nonadmin Close review at Alternative for Germany 22 April 2017 Talk:Alternative for Germany/Archive 4#RfC: Should "Climate change denial" be listed in the "Ideology" list in the infobox? [87] No change
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive288#Requesting review on closure of Wikipedia:Requests for comment/RfC to adopt a default gender neutral style for policy, guidelines and help pages 6 May 2017 Wikipedia:Requests for comment/RfC to adopt a default gender neutral style for policy, guidelines and help pages [88] Reopened and reclosed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive288#Request for the re-opening of a closed RfC 7 May 2017 Wikipedia talk:Noticeboard for India-related topics/Archive 64#RfC on Indicscript in infoboxes [89] [90] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive290#Disputed RFC close at Controversial Reddit communities 14 June 2017 Talk:Controversial Reddit communities/Archive 1#RfC Including SRS as a Controversial Reddit Community [91] [92] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive291#Requesting closure review 25 August 2017 Talk:Westworld (TV series)/Archive 4#RfC on Potential Spoilers [93] Reopened
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive294#RfC close review: Algerian War 28 October 2017 Talk:Algerian War/Archive 4#RfC about the result parameter in the Infobox [94] Endorsed
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result

2018[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive296#Request review of closure at Disk storage 27 January 2018 Talk:Disk storage#RfC on "data are" or "data is" [95] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive297#Pre- and post-nominals discussion needs reopening 19 February 2018 Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Schools/Article guidelines/Archive 2#Pre-nominals and post-nominals [96] No change
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive299#Closure Review of Talk:Nicholas Hoult#Infobox 23 May 2018 Talk:Nicholas Hoult/Archive 1#Infobox [97] Moot; another RfC created
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive301#Review of NAC at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject UK Railways 6 August 2018 Wikipedia talk:WikiProject UK Railways/Archive 43#Chains RFC [98] Reclosed by uninvolved admin
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive301#Close review 14 August 2018 Talk:Feynman Prize in Nanotechnology#!Vote about list format [99] No consensus to overturn; new RfC permitted; new RfC started
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive301#RfC close review 23 August 2018 Talk:Donald Trump/Archive 91#RfC: Should the lead include a sentence about Trump's racial stance? [100] [101] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive302#Challenging Close of section in RSN 16 September 2018 Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard/Archive 248#Motion to Procedurally Close for Lack of Neutrally Worded Question [102] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive303#Contesting formal closure of RfC by an involved editor 17 November 2018 Talk:Boy (album)#RfC: Should two scores from Rolling Stone, from the same year, be included in the ratings box? [103] RfC reclosed by uninvolved editor
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive305#Closure of RfC: Nikola Tesla's birthplace 12 December 2018 Talk:Nikola Tesla/Nationality and ethnicity/Archive 11#RfC: Nikola Tesla's birthplace (in need of objective editors) [104] Endorsed
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result

2019[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive307#Closure of Wikipedia talk:Naming conventions (television)#RfC on using US or U.S. 17 February 2019 Wikipedia talk:Naming conventions (television)/Archive 15#RfC on using US or U.S. [105] Closer amended close
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive307#WP:CLOSECHALLENGE 10 March 2019 Talk:Antisemitism in the UK Labour Party/Archive 7#RfC.4 IJV/JSG/JVP / Oryszczuk [106] Challenge retracted in favor of a different approach
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive307#RfC Closure Review (Talk:RuPaul's Drag Race) 25 March 2019 Talk:RuPaul's Drag Race#RfC on names of transgender contestants [107] Reopened and reclosed by an uninvolved editor
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive308#RfC Closure Review for RuPaul's Drag Race 14 April 2019 Talk:RuPaul's Drag Race#RfC on names of transgender contestants [108] No consensus to overturn. Endorsed by an uninvolved admin.
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive308#Requesting Closure review of Ilhan Omar RfC 22 April 2019 Talk:Ilhan Omar/Archive 7#Request for Comment: Should Anti-semitism accusations be included in the lede? [109] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive309#RFC Closure review 3 June 2019 Talk:Cossack Hetmanate#RfC Merge [110] Review archived without result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive311#Close review - Village Pump discussion on spelling of category names 26 June 2019 Wikipedia:Village pump (policy)/Archive 153#RFC: spelling of "organisation"/"organization" in descriptive category names [111] Overturn to no consensus, with no prejudice against speedy renomination
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive312#Closure review- Order of paragraphs in lead of MEK article 7 July 2019 Talk:People's Mujahedin of Iran/Archive 14#RFC about order of paragraphs in lead [112] No consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive314#Refusal to acknowledge RfC closure 23 July 2019 Talk:Tulsi Gabbard/Archive 2#RfC: Tulsi Gabbard's views on foreign policy [113] No change
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive312#Improper WP:RFC closure on Talk:Richard B. Spencer. 18 August 2019 Talk:Richard B. Spencer/Archive 6#RfC: Neo-Nazi label [114] RfC reopened and reclosed by uninvolved admin with the same result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive314#Requesting closure review 25 September 2019 Talk:Suicide methods#RFC: Hatnote at top [115] Endorsed
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result


2020[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive318#Request for closure review 15 March 2020 Talk:Naval Air Station Pensacola shooting#Add names of victims who died [116] [117] [118] [119] Close self-reverted
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive318#RfC closure review request 16 March 2020 Talk:Ronan Farrow#RfC Ronan’s coming out [120] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive318#Close review please 27 March 2020 Talk:2019–20 coronavirus pandemic/Archive 25#Proposal: Move moratorium [121] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive319#Another close review please 3 April 2020 Talk:Julian Assange#RfC about German appeal [122] Endorsed
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive319#Review of RfC close by User:Cunard 8 April 2020 Talk:Electronic cigarette#RfC: Article readability [123] Archived without result; effectively, no consensus to overturn
Wikipedia:Administrators'_noticeboard/Archive319#Self-requested_closure_review:_RfC_on_race_and_intelligence 21 April 2020 wikipedia:Fringe_theories/Noticeboard/Archive_70 [124] Endorsed
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result

2021[edit]

Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result
Wikipedia:Administrators'_noticeboard/Archive331#Challenge_to_non-admin_closure_of_RfC_at_BLP_article_Emanuel_Cleaver 13 March 2021 Talk:Emanuel_Cleaver#RfC_about_Amen_&_Awomen [125] Non-admin closer vacated his/her closure; administrator subsequently closed RfC as no consensus, thus default to exclude
Closure review Start date Discussion reviewed Diff of close Result

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Administrators%27_noticeboard/Closure_review_archive&oldid=1136029232"




●This page was last edited on 28 January 2023, at 09:24 (UTC).
●Text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 4.0; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Wikipedia® is a registered trademark of the Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., a non-profit organization.


●Privacy policy
●About Wikipedia
●Disclaimers
●Contact Wikipedia
●Code of Conduct
●Developers
●Statistics
●Cookie statement
●Mobile view


Wikimedia Foundation
Powered by MediaWiki