This is a self-nomination. I believe the list currently meets all of the FL criteria: it covers an important topic, is stable and non-controversial, fully referenced and has a nice layout. Moreover, there are currently only three monarchy-related featured lists on Wikipedia, so a new addition would be good. All objections of course will be promptly addressed.BomBom (talk) 19:39, 24 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Oppose
lots of MOS issues especially Y
First and third paragraphs in the lead have no references Y
"1805 till 1953." – "1805 until 1953."??? Y
"1805-1867" – year ranges use en dashes per WP:DASHY
page ranges in references use en dashes Y
"13 - 19 March 2003" –『13–19 March 2003』etc. Y
"nineteenth century" – I think consensus is to spell out centuries so "19th century" Y
En dash for date ranges—one there needs to be spaced. Please see MOS:DASH.
Table: can you manipulate the column widths to give more to "Fate" in the second table: the text is like skyscrapers. Tony(talk) 08:35, 27 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Y Done. Your comments have been taken into account. BomBom (talk) 14:19, 27 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
I don't like the use of colour in columns that big, would it be possible to remove all the green colouring and just use grey? Also, could you make the images a little smaller? -- Scorpion0422 16:53, 30 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Y Done. I replaced the green background with a light gray one, and reduced the size of the images to 80px. BomBom (talk) 18:29, 30 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]
Comments
I don't understand what all the pink is for.
Are you sure Isma'il Pasha's reign in the Ottoman province didn't end on 7 June, and he begin with the Ottoman Khedivate on 8 June? What I mean is was he granted the title of Khedive on 8 June and he used it immediately, or was he granted it before 8 June, and he became Khedive as soon as the clock struck midnight?
Why aren't there full entries for Aziz Ezzat Pasha, Prince Muhammad Ali and Sherif Sabri Pasha?
Same for the rows after the Revolution
Why is the table header "Revolution" written as "R E V O L U T I O N"? This causes WP:ACCESS problems with screen readers.
Per Wikipedia:CITE#Citation templates and tools and WP:CITET, {{citation}} shouldn't be used on the same page as {{cite web}}, {{cite book}} or anything else in the {{cite xxx}} range. I know that the citation ones are being used for {{harvnb}}, but as I've found out from my nominations -- it doesn't matter. All the reference templates should be converted to citation, or lose the harvard referencing function. :(
Isma'il Pasha obtained the Ottoman firman (i.e. decree) appointing him as wāli on 8 June 1867, and the decree had immediate effect.
It seems to me the answer is pretty obvious from the article itself. Aziz Ezzat Pasha, Prince Muhammad Ali and Sherif Sabri Pasha were regents. Therefore, there should be a distinction between them and the other monarchs.
Same answer regarding the rows after the Revolution.
The "Revolution" table header has been fixed.
All reference templates have been converted to citation.